Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented

(seremot.com)

79 points | by emot 5 hours ago

7 comments

  • jibalt 30 minutes ago
    I knew Vint when I worked in the UCLA CompSci dept under Steve Crocker. Both were super nice guys. (Jon Postel, the third in the Van Nuys High triumvirate, was far more inscrutable.)
  • meialabscom 5 hours ago
    I feel like this sort of long term thinking is not likley to happen now. Are we too focused on monetization now? I feel this is mostly the influence of VC's in "innovation".
    • robmusial 4 hours ago
      Signal Protocol, RISC-V, WireGuard just off the top of my head are pretty major recent innovations that aren't patent encumbered. There are plenty of people doing interesting work not influenced by VC money.
      • kstenerud 49 minutes ago
        JSON, HTTP, Markdown, CSV, HTML, almost every programming language, SSH, AV1, ODF, Open protocol, Linux, POSIX, OpenGL, Wayland, Vulkan, Opus, SeaBIOS, GCC, LLVM, LXC, USB...
      • lioeters 2 hours ago
        I read that if we didn't have public libraries and someone suggested the concept these days, it would never be built because it sounds like a socialist scheme. "Free access to books and self-education! Who does that profit?" Everyone, of course, society benefits.

        But there are good examples of technology for public benefit, and the more I pay attention, I see people are making efforts in various spaces, not just in technology but a variety of social activism on collective and personal level.

        The Internet, the web, and personal computers were miraculous for that historical period, it liberated the creative energy of following generations. The accelerating enshittification of our present time has managed to capture a lot of that value and cultural relevance, but the cutting edge has moved on elsewhere to find fresh expression.

        That is to say, I believe there is hope as long as people continue to engage with meaningful projects creating value for the commons, and even the toxic atmosphere of global exploitation may turn out to be the wake-up call and challenge for humanity to manifest social changes, including socially beneficial technological innovations, for a better future.

        • frankling_ 26 minutes ago
          [...] but the cutting edge has moved on elsewhere to find fresh expression.

          Any pointers? Been looking for these elsewheres.

        • morcatabiew 1 hour ago
          Wikipedia, archive, ocw
        • miki123211 33 minutes ago
          If libraries were invented in the 21st century, it would have been by a Silicon Valley entrepreneur "disrupting the copyright monopollies" with the innovative practice of "book sharing". They would quickly be criticized by authors and journalists alike and banned by some local governments.

          Libraries that required their members to pay fees did in fact exist historically. It's how many libraries in the US got started. They were private enterprises meant to make money (or at least be self-sustaining non-profits relying on a mix of donations and fees), not government-run projects.

          Libraries are an obvious workaround for the western copyright system[1]. Because this system lets us share existing book copies without the permission of the author, but doesn't allow us to print new ones for free even when the capability exists, the obvious way to make books cheaper is to serially share them across many readers and have each pay the fraction of the price. This is essentially what these libraries did, with fees as a stand-in for the price sharing that simplified their operation.

          [1] Yes, I'm aware that copyright isn't exactly necessary for libraries to exist; high printing costs would do it too. I do think that they would be entirely unnecessary and almost extinct (in well-functioning 21st-century democracies) if not for copyright, given our printing costs.

    • wmf 2 hours ago
      I think people appreciate the power of free and open standards much more now than in previous decades. Companies have shifted to more subtle forms of monetization than just making everything proprietary.
      • miki123211 30 minutes ago
        Open standards have much better network effects, and so they're generally favored by the market.

        Companies would prefer for their standards to be proprietary, but open standards products often do better than proprietary ones, because of said network effects.

        This is not always true; sometimes the open standard and the required interoperability hampers innovation, hence why most enterprised moved off of standards-based Cisco products to Slack and Zoom.

    • abofh 2 hours ago
      Well, exactly. His boss wasn't measuring him by patents
    • ares623 32 minutes ago
      Yes. The "open web" would be considered an abject failure of maximizing revenue and shareholder value.
    • jbmchuck 3 hours ago
      Yup. Now it would be called a moat.
  • Ey7NFZ3P0nzAe 3 hours ago
    Reminds me of:

    > - Who owns the patent on this vaccine?

    > - Jonas Salk: Well, the people, I would say. There is no patent. Could you patent the sun?

    - Jonas Edward Salk (October 28 1914 – June 23 1995) was a medical researcher and author, the inventor of the Salk vaccine against Polio

    • crossroadsguy 42 minutes ago
      > Could you patent the sun?

      I, maybe a decade younger, would have said "never", "that's silly". Now? I am not sure. Hear me out. Imagine a scenario where someone had patented "harnessing energy from the sun using semiconductors and electrical circuits" and then can enforce that to a large part of the world. I mean what depresses me that it doesn't infeasible to me at all. Least of it will be the patent grant.

    • saghm 3 hours ago
      Also worth remembering that the Eisenhower administration tried to resist giving the vaccine out for free because it was "socialized medicine".
      • rexpop 36 minutes ago
        Yes, senator Barry Goldwater likewise characterized a government vaccination program as “socialized medicine by the back door, not the front door.”

        Goldwater would later to on to commit such atrocities as voting against the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and floating the use of atomic weapons in Vietnam.

  • emot 5 hours ago
    full transcript here: ourfuturestories.eu/vint-cerf
  • JSR_FDED 1 hour ago
    I was in a meeting with Vint Cerf 20+ years ago. He’s an engineer’s engineer and you immediately pick up on the combination of intelligence, focus, discipline and an ability to zoom out and see the bigger picture. Very impressive. He’s also humble and very approachable - and dresses better than you :-)
    • jibalt 25 minutes ago
      When I worked for the UCLA CompSci dept in 1969 I dressed like a hippie (as did Jon Postel and many others), but Vint always wore a 3-piece suit and carried a briefcase. (His bud Steve Crocker was more a pocket protector engineer type.)
  • 7e 1 hour ago
    In the early 70s the government owned most DARPA-funded research. So there would have been little point to pursuing a patent.
  • acheron 2 hours ago
    And then he went to work for Google.
    • paul7986 1 hour ago
      I heard him speak at Google in DC in 2014. It was interesting...
      • wetwater 55 minutes ago
        anything in particular ?