Greg Kurtzer's Ginux is now a userspace kernel

(github.com)

37 points | by d3Xt3r 1 hour ago

2 comments

  • asdfsa32 41 minutes ago
    This is kind of the wrong approach when linux namespaces exist and rootless namespaces are approach full spectrum.
    • stingraycharles 23 minutes ago
      I’m still fascinated by the approach, though. It seems to me that it sits somewhere between cgroups and virtual machines.

      I do wonder what problem it solves, as I don’t think that it provides the same security guarantees that micro-VMs like firecracker do?

      • eddythompson80 16 minutes ago
        It’s the same approach as gVisor. Fairly decent isolation if your application can work on it, but your SOL if a scenario comes up that doesn’t work. VMs give you pretty much 100% Linux compatibility at the expense of density, optimal resource allocation and startup time. gVisor gives you excellent startup time, resource allocation and density at the expense of some app compat and performance at the extremes

        Edit: at least with gvisor you get close to a decade of work on compat. gVisor can support some rootless containers scenarios and systemd these days.

    • photios 1 minute ago
      > Telling someone's research and exploration is wrong...

      Never change, HN, never change :D

  • up2isomorphism 53 minutes ago
    The issue with this kind of thing is nobody will take it seriously.
    • mbreese 47 minutes ago
      Why? Because a user space kernel is a bad idea? Or because of the AI use when writing it?

      I’m still trying to figure out exactly what it is.

      • up2isomorphism 36 minutes ago
        Why should someone spend anytime on this kind of technical piece that is not created by human? Think about what you will get from this, the answer is pretty obvious.