USB Floppy Disk Striped RAID Under OS X (2004)

(web.archive.org)

33 points | by donnachangstein 3 days ago

7 comments

  • rzzzt 2 hours ago
    The 8-Bit Guy (formerly iBook Guy) created an array using USB sticks: https://youtu.be/dougISKs2vQ

    Action Retro has a video with floppies: https://youtu.be/1hc52_PWeU8

    He also references a MacWorld article with Daniel's array: https://www.macworld.com/article/165663/floppyraid.html

    • geerlingguy 11 minutes ago
      Was going to post the Action Retro attempt. Latency is abysmal, yet it's still a glorious thing to see it (kinda) work at all.

      Need to see if someone can hack together RAID on cassettes on an old Apple II

  • somat 1 hour ago
    I have done it with usb floppy drives under openbsd, I am sure it is just as trivial under linux but I had obsd and a bunch of usb floppy drives at my disposal.

        #it has been a few years I don't remember if it works with bare drives or if you need a disklabel on each floppy
        bioctl -c 5 -l /dev/sd2c,/dev/sd3c,/dev/sd4c softraid0
        #the raid will show up now, check dmesg
        disklabel -E sd5
        newfs /dev/sd5a
        mount /dev/sd5a /mnt/floppy/
        umount /mnt/floppy
        bioctl -d sd5
        #after inserting all floppies reassemble the raid
        bioctl -c 5 -l /dev/sd2c,/dev/sd3c,/dev/sd4c softraid0
        mount /dev/sd5a /mnt/floppy
        
    I love it when a system like this A. does not try to railroad you into the "correct path" and B. the independent layers actually work independently.

    One day in what was probably sullen resentment that openbsd has no equivalent to DRBD I assembled a raid on iscsi drives, that is, initiate 5 iscsi sessions to independent hosts then assemble a raid with them. and you can imagine my surprise when it very nearly worked, I could read and write just fine. The part that did not work was drive failure. My guess is that iscsid did not fail a drive in a way that softraid understood. so a drive failure just lead to everything hanging.

  • irusensei 42 minutes ago
    Not floppies but I clearly remember some Sun Microsystems video demonstrating ZFS where some guys dressed as over the top engineers randomly disconnecting USB thumb drives that were part of a pool to show the file system resilience.
  • tombert 1 hour ago
    I thought about trying this with LTO drives, to have a ridiculously slow but also ridiculously high capacity raid, but sadly the LTO tape decks are a bit too expensive for this experiment.
    • kevin_thibedeau 20 minutes ago
      U320 SCSI LTO-5 can be had cheap. Nobody wants them these days.
  • mrweasel 2 hours ago
    There is a YouTube video on the Action Retro channel, where this article is used as inspiration. Apparently you're not able to use any random floppy drive, but you can use more than five.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1hc52_PWeU8

  • jmclnx 3 hours ago
    I remember reading something like this a very long time ago. It must have been about what this guy did. Real cool.
  • rideontime 3 hours ago
    He's not wrong, Riviera is pretty groovy. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLvjLW0i-2Ebq9iQoZ-m2R...